There are many different toilet tank lids on the market, but how do you know which one is right for your toilet? There are four things to consider when choosing a new toilet tank lid. These include color, material, size, and style of the handle. Let’s take a look at each one individually to help you choose the best fit for your home!

Four Things To Choose The Right Toilet Tank Lids

If you want to choose the right one, you should check and confirm these 4 things about a toilet tank lid:

  1. Color
  2. Material
  3. Size
  4. Style of the Handle

Now we will discuss these 4 things for you. So, you can understand easily and choose the perfect toilet tank lid for your bathroom.

Let’s go!

The Color

The color of your toilet tank lid will depend on the rest of your bathroom. Toilet tank lids come in a variety of colors, including gold and white porcelain for a more modern feel or copper to go with an antique look. If you don’t want something that stands out too much then choose one from the same color family as your toilet seat!

The Material

You have a few options when it comes to toilet tank lids – plastic, porcelain, or metal. The material of your toilet tank lid depends on how you want it to look and how much work is involved. Plastics are easier to clean, but they don’t have the same sleekness as porcelain or copper. Toilet tank lids made from these materials might not be so easy to find and may cost a little more, but the look is worth it in some cases!

If your existing lid is made from plastic then chances are that this will also be the best option for your new one (although not always). They’re cheap and easy to replace as they often become scratched and faded with use but if you want something more expensive-looking there’s an array of colors available including white, chrome, or brushed nickel which all look great on black toilets! You may get some problems installing them though because newer models sometimes come with complicated connections underneath that make installation difficult without being able to see what you’re doing so again just pop down to Home Depot or Lowe’s beforehand and they’ll be able to help you out.

The Size

Toilet tank lids come in a range of sizes to suit different toilet bowl shapes and heights. Your new lid must fit on top of the existing pipe which you can measure by wrapping a string around it – this should be between 19-25 inches tall for an American Standard toilet. This measurement will give you the thickness of your replacement toilet seat as well so make sure to also account for these measurements when looking at how big or small they are.

If you’re not 100% certain about what size would work best then just pop down to Home Depot or Lowe’s with their tape measure and ask them – they’ll know exactly where everything is located and can help you out.

Note: No matter what your toilet is made from, the lid should match in terms of color and materials so make sure that this matters before purchasing one! If it’s white porcelain then go for an all-white plastic or brass look with a nice curve on the top edges if possible, whereas if it’s black then chrome is probably the best option (although not always due to how expensive these can be). Again just ask at Home Depot for advice – everyone there knows their stuff about toilets!

Costs and Installation

Price ranges vary greatly but as a rough estimate expect anything between $20-$90 depending on where you get them from. They’re easy to install yourself – just make sure you read the instructions first (it’s always best to have a professional do it though as they will know what to look out for), and use your favorite toolbox!

Here is A List of Kits to Install a Toilet Tank Lid:

To install a toilet tank lid, you need these:

  • Toilet tank lid
  • Toolbox
  • DIY installation kit
  • Instruction manual
  • Quick-release clip

Follow these step by step guidelines to install the toilet tank lid:

Insert the toilet tank lid into place. Use a quick-release clip to secure it securely in position at the top of the toilet tank. Make sure that you have positioned it correctly and all clips are engaged properly. Measure around your old toilet tank opening with a tape measure, mark with chalk or pencil then use this measurement for setting up new toilet tanks so you get an exact fit every time!

Install any other accessories onto your new toilets such as slow close seats or bracketless handrails (if required). Follow instructions on how to install these parts found in the installation kit manual – they’re usually easy!

American Standard Toilet Tank Lid

American Standard has been around for over 100 years and they are a well-known company. They have different shapes, patterns, colors, etc.

The American Standard toilet tank lids come in three slightly different designs which include round corners with no lip on the edge (model number 415), oval-shaped edges that still have no lip on the edge (model number 417) or square edges with a fuller rounded shape along its top rim to accommodate larger items such as rolls of toilet paper (Model Number 419). These models cost between $37-$42 but there are some cheaper ones at about $33 if you’re looking to save money.

Kohler toilet tank lid K-3717 is designed for incorporation into Kohler toilets that utilize the swing-out flush valve.


If you are a newbie, don’t buy any toilet tank lid from any new shop. Because it might not fit your toilet.

Then what will you do?

The best suggestion is to buy a toilet tank lid from a reliable store. Example: Hope you got the point.

How to Measure Toilet Tank Lid?

To measure the size of your toilet, you will need some measurements that can be found on the inside rim with no lip around it or in one of the corners. These measurements are usually measured in inches and include length (L), width (W), and height (H).

How to Choose the Right Toilet Tank Lid?

To choose the right toilet tank lid, you will need to measure your old one and then find a new one that matches. Be sure when measuring both of them are in inches or with metric measurements as well. Now, all we do is follow the guideline that we already described in the article.


Toilet tank lids are an overlooked item in the bathroom. However, toilet tank lids can be a major problem if they have been severely corroded or broken by accident. If you would like to know more about this issue and how to fix it, read our blog for more information on how we fixed our toilet tank lid using these steps:

  • Step #1: Use your hands to clean off any corrosion from the top of the screws that hold down the cover;
  • Step #2: Apply some Vaseline around where those two screw holes are located (this will help with rusting);
  • Step #3: Turn over your toilet seat so you can get underneath it;
  • Step #4: Find something heavy enough-like a rock-to place inside.

And finally, if you see the problem is still there, just change it. Read the article from the top, then you can understand how will you do it.